My dogs, Paige Turner and Seven, are notorious hoarders. Paige Turner has a secret stash. Every few days, I find one of her favorite toys—sometimes the squeaky squirrel, sometimes the donut—neatly tucked away as if she’s saving it for later. Seven, on the other hand, prefers treats over toys, unless it’s his big boy ball. He’ll guard that special Chuckit! in his mouth like a treasure. So, why do dogs hoard their toys?
I used to wonder why they did this until I realized there’s real meaning behind the behavior.
Why Dogs Hoard Their Toys
According to experts, when dogs gather toys in one spot, it’s not just cute – it’s instinct. Long before dogs became our companions, their ancestors stored food and valued items for safekeeping. That ancient instinct still shows up in today’s living rooms. Hoarding provides comfort and control, especially after big changes like moving, adding a new pet, or dealing with emotional stress. It’s their way of restoring a sense of order and belonging.
So, when Paige Turner builds her toy pile or Seven curls around his favorite ball, I see something more profound than play. They’re not being greedy – they’re creating a stash of comfort. Each toy is a piece of their world that feels safe, familiar, and entirely theirs, a way to mark what matters most in a day full of smells, sounds, and change.
So the next time you see toys lined up on the couch or hidden under your pillow, remember this: your dog isn’t being possessive. They’re practicing self-care, dog style.
When Hoarding Crosses the Line
Most toy hoarding is harmless and even kind of adorable. But if your dog begins protecting their stash, experts agree that’s no longer hoarding, it’s resource guarding, and it needs to be addressed.
Things to watch out for
- Body stiff and frozen when you approach.
- Lowered head over the object, with a hard stare or “whale eye” (showing the whites).
- Growling, snarling, snapping, or biting if you get too close.
- Lunging at other pets that come close to the hoard.
If you notice these signs, expert trainers say don’t punish or “correct” the growl; that’s just your dog’s warning system. Instead, focus on changing how they feel about people near their belongings. A few basics to get started, according to seasoned trainers:
- Trade, don’t grab. Teach a gentle “trade” or “give” by offering a high-value treat (like tiny bits of chicken or cheese) in exchange for the toy, then frequently give the toy back so they learn you’re not a thief.
- Toss treats as you pass. When you walk by their pile, drop a treat nearby without reaching for the toys. Over time, your presence near their stash predicts good things, not loss.
- Teach cues early. Practice “drop it” and “leave it” in calm situations using rewards and praise, so those skills are ready before emotions escalate.
- Manage the environment. If certain toys are trouble spots, limit access to them unless you’re present to supervise and train.
If the guarding is intense, such as biting, full-on attacks, or escalating over time, consult a force-free trainer or veterinary behaviorist who can develop a plan tailored to your dog.
Dogs hoarding toys for comfort? Totally normal. Guarding them with fear or aggression? That’s your cue to step in kindly and help your dog feel safe enough to share their world.
A Few Toys My Dogs Love to Hoard
Since we’re discussing why dogs hoard their toys, here are a few of my dogs’ favorites:
1. A Big Ball For Having a Ball
If your dog is like Seven, the Chuckit! Kick Fetch Ball could become their new favorite. Designed to trigger natural chasing and fetching instincts, this large ball can be kicked, thrown, or punted for hours of fun. Its deep bite zones make it easy for dogs to grab and carry, even during wild games of keep-away in the yard. And the material is designed to not hurt their teeth.
Why dogs hoard it: Its unpredictable bounce—perfect for dogs who thrive on surprise and movement.
Bonus: Made from durable rubber, foam, and rugged canvas, it’s gentle on mouths yet tough enough for rough-and-tumble play.
2. Hidden Toys Within a Toy
This plush puzzle, Outward Hound Hide-a-Squirrel Puzzle Toy, is practically made for hoarders. Dogs like Paige love digging out the squeaky squirrels, carrying them around, and piling them into their beds for safekeeping. Plus, it’s like six toys in one!
Why dogs hoard it: Multiple “babies” to collect and protect—ideal for nurturing types like Paige.
Bonus: Mentally stimulating and endlessly entertaining.
3. Cute, Cuddly, and Comforting
Originally designed for puppies with separation anxiety, Snuggle Puppy Heartbeat Stuffed Toy mimics the warmth and heartbeat of a companion. Many dogs treat it like a comfort object, often carrying it around or sleeping beside it.
Why dogs hoard it: It feels alive, familiar, and soothing.
Bonus: Perfect for rescue dogs or pups adjusting to a new home.
4. Donuts!
Who doesn’t like donuts? Zippy Paws Donutz Plush Toy is lightweight, squeaky, and easy to grab—dogs love these donut-shaped toys. They’re often collected and displayed like colorful trophies.
Why dogs hoard it: Easy to carry, soft to cuddle, and fun to squeak.
Bonus: No stuffing means less mess if they “deflate” one.
5. Chew and Chew . . . and Hide It
For dogs who enjoy chewing and hiding things, Nylabone Power Chew Rextured Ring is ideal and long-lasting. You’ll often find it tucked under blankets or in their favorite spots.
Why dogs hoard it: Tough, flavorful, and satisfying to gnaw on.
Bonus: Excellent for dental health and stress relief.
🐾 Want more dog stories, training tips, recommendations, and heart-to-heart reflections?
Join me on BlissDog on Substack — where I share the lessons my dogs teach me about love, purpose, and the everyday magic of life with paws.
(Our site may contain links to affiliate websites, and we receive an affiliate commission for any purchases made by you on the affiliate website using such links.)